dark souls 3 endings explanation

There are two possible ending for Dark Souls: "To Link the Fire" and "The Dark Lord". Dark Souls 3 Endings. However, she mentions that some small sparks still exist that permit another to come and relight the flame once more. 2. Dying twice after each sigil gained will accrue enough hollowing to gain the next. From Software's Dark Souls 3 has multiple different endings. The remaining 4 sigils are given at 2, 6, 12, and 18 hollowing respectively. What follows is a grim cutscene where the player-character slays the Firekeeper in cold blood and attempts to claim the First Flame for themselves. Dark Souls III. Share on Facebook; Share on Twitter; Share on Pinterest; Share on Tumblr; Share on Reddit; Dark Souls III contains three very different endings. Like every chapter of the saga, also Dark Souls 3 presents more endings that must be achieved by completing some quests and taking specific actions during the course of the adventure. One sigil is given for free. Dark Souls can be pretty dense. There are implications that an Unkindled is the remains of an Undead warrior who failed to link … Dark Season 3 Ending Explained: What Happened in the Final Episode By Sadie Gennis @sadiegennis Jun 28, 2020 12:55 PM EDT [Warning: The following contains spoilers for Dark Season 3. One of the standard features of most Soulslike games are the multiple, oftentimes confusing endings that come with them. Immediately, head to Firelink Shrine and speak with, Head back to Catacombs and speak with Anri before crossing the bridge leading to, If the player tells Anri where Horace is, Anri will seek out Horace and eventually go. Below, is a guide on how to In this ending, the Ashen One attempts to do as all the other lords had done before them and link the fire. Ultimately, someone else always comes in to rekindle the Flame. Although they aren't that long, they're pretty cool to watch. The Fire Keeper is thrown to the ground and the player holds her head down with their foot, reaching toward the flame still in her hands. Originally, Dark Souls 2 funneled players into one ending, which made the protagonist sit on the Throne of Want. Dark Season 3 took the already complicated series to brand new heights, but it can be difficult to follow exactly what happened. Dark Souls 3's third ending is merely an extension of the second. In Dark Souls III, there are four endings from which the player may choose: To Link the First Flame The End of Fire The End of Fire (alternate) The Usurpation of Fire This ending is obtained by lighting thebonfirethat appears after defeating theSoul of Cinder. If you’ve already beaten Dark Souls 3, there’s a good chance that this was the ending you received because all you need to do is collect the throneless Lords of Cinder, return them to their stoney chairs, and then skip along to the Kiln of the First Flame. To Link The Fire Triggered by defeating Gwyn, Lord of Cinder and lighting the final bonfire. Apr 30, 2016 @ 4:46pm True ending, in my opinion #6. Related: Why The Moonlight Greatsword Is In Ever Dark Souls Game. Full spoilers for an explanation on all the endings of Dark Souls III and whether or not they're a good way to end the series. The world is mysterious and actively trying to kill you, but why? There are four endings in the game and three trophies/achievements available to unlock. Unfortunately, Dark Souls II reveals that the two ages are inescapably, unnaturally linked, and no matter which ending the player chooses the opportunity for the opposing age to arise always presents itself. In the brief time where the player still has control of their character while the Firekeeper does her dirty deed, they must attack her. Dark Souls 3 is perhaps the worst offender when it comes to this, with a grand total of four endings that often require completely different playthroughs to achieve. For other uses, see Ending (disambiguation). When ready, head back to our Dark Souls 3 walkthrough and guide for more tips and advice!. There are a total of 4 endings in Dark Souls 3. Requirements: Painted World of Ariandel: Defeat Sister Friede in the Chapel of Ariandel. Before Dark Souls 3's endings are explained, it's important to understand how they fit in with Dark Souls' established lore, otherwise none of them will make any sense. r/TwoBestFriendsPlay: A place where fans of the content that Matt, Pat, and Woolie provide come to talk about their content and anything revolving … In each game, the player can either extend their Age of Fire or end it. Warning: SPOILERS for Dark season 3.. The Ashen One stretches out a hand and begins to burn, but unlike in the past, the fire is not reborn. And only did that ending once so didn't notice the reference, now the Gundyr and Twin Princes Greatsword I did notice. Dark season 3 ending explained. Feb 25, 2010 9,700 1,529 1,015. You play as a protagonist whose goal is to find and return the five Lords of Cinder to their thrones at Firelink Shrine in order to link the flame again. Dark Souls 3 Endings Unlike the previous games, Dark Souls 3 actually has three endings, but also unlike the previous game, they are all almost identical. Login Store Home Discovery Queue Wishlist Points Shop News Stats PappyBakesCakes. It requires an extremely lengthy explanation, so your best bet here would be to either watch the video below, or delve into the Dark Souls 3 … 3) Kill Aldritch and go talk to Yuria. ENDING 3 OF Dark Souls 3 - USURPATION OF FIRE This is the most complex endinge of the game and by unlocking it you also get the appropriate trophy/goal. Take the sword to Anri--who's now located in a room further down the hall--and interact with her to initiate the marriage. This ending is fairly tricky to obtain as it requires quite a few steps. From there, Yoel's replacement, Yuria, will instruct the player on where they may participate in a wedding ceremony. Dark Souls 3 - How to unlock all the endings Our guide to how to see the all the variations of Dark Souls 3's ending: The End of Fire, The End of Fire+, and Usurpation of Fire. Mig. However, things are different in Dark Souls 3. The meaning was left ambiguous, but many assumed this meant rekindling the Flame. DARK season 3 brought the expansive German sci-fi series to a conclusion on June 27, 2020 after the final cycle arrived on Netflix. Ending 3: Usurpation of Fire. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. So far, we know there are four endings for Dark Souls 3, each one requiring an additional layer of complexity to unlock. Existence itself has become weakened by this ongoing cycle after millennia of switching between them. )". The "Usurpation of Fire" is the third ending; it requires a strict questline to be completed. Read at your own risk!] The questline finishes with the defeat of the. Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2014 10:17 pm. To get this ending, simply reach the final boss--the Soul of Cinder. SPOILERS (Duh! Dark Souls 3 - The Usurpation of Fire Ending Trophy / Achievement Guide - Reach "The Usurpation of Fire" ending. Endings for Dark Souls and Dark Souls Remastered offers detailed guides on being able to acquire the various endings of the story. Here is the Dark Season 3 ending, explained. To unlock a final conversation, offering a cryptic explanation for the events of the game, you'll need to complete both Dark Souls 3 add-ons. Many kingdoms have risen and fallen, and the Flame has been rekindled an unknown number of times. As the screen fades to black after the Fire Keeper speaks, the player can control their character for a few seconds and can attack her. Of all the endings in Dark Souls 3, this one is meant for those who simply played without trying to tease out Dark Souls 3’s deep mysteries. Instead, the Ashen One merely sits beside the flame, seemingly unable to prolong its life, as the sun remains a Darksign. If you are looking for a quick overview of the game's walkthrough , follow our recommended Game Progress Route. Dark season 3 introduced an entirely new world and finally broke the cycle that had trapped Jonas and the rest of the characters in a never-ending time loop. At the ending to Dark Souls 2, You defeat Nashandra, the queen of Drangleic. Dark Souls 3's third ending is merely an extension of the second. You play as a protagonist whose goal is to find and return the five Lords of Cinder to their thrones at Firelink Shrine in order to link the flame again. The default ending means you don’t have all eight Dark Sigils and you basically just lit the bonfire after defeating the Soul of Cinder final boss. To get it you have to carry out a quest that branches off throughout the adventure. What follows is a grim cutscene where the player-character slays the Firekeeper in cold blood and attempts to claim the First Flame for themselves. Find Anri in the Catacombs of Carthus in a hallway next to the first rolling skeleton ball. Talk with Yuria at Firelink Shrine and exhaust her dialogue. To get this ending, the player must first give the Eyes of a Fire Keeper to the Fire Keeper and summon her after defeating the Soul of Cinder. All the primordial serpents bow before the new ruler, the Chosen Undead, who has thus become the "Dark Lord". So, we’re here to break down exactly what Dark Souls 3 endings there are, and how to get all endings in the game. The remaining 4 sigils are given a… ****Bloodsouls is developed by only me, so please give me time time to fix bugs, update areas, icons, descriptions ect...**** Also, im no pro just a dude with a hobby YOUNGPLATANO. By Matt Espineli on April 18, 2016 at 5:03PM PDT. Obviously I don't because I am scared I wont be able to level up for the rest of my playthrough, and I think it triggers an ending which causes the fire to fade. The final season of Dark has arrived, and while the ending of the show explained many of its mysteries, there still a few questions left to answer. Ending 1: To Link the First Flame To Link the First Flame is the easiest ending to obtain in Dark Souls III. I did it on my first Dark Souls 3 Jap version playthrough. One sigil is given for free. Default Ending. As such it is probably best to do it on a second playthrough so that you know where things occur. Dark Souls 3 probably takes place after Dark Souls 2, but it doesn't matter really, because both are essentially different threads of a divergent universe. Souls: 0.00 . Login Store Home Discovery Queue Wishlist Points Shop News Stats The second ending is not much better, but it is a bit more complex. 1) Make sure to get all 5 dark sigils from Yoel of Londor by leveling up for free from him. Neme-ita requested i do this, so this is for you buddy. The Dark Souls storylines are difficult enough to work out at the best of times, but what if Dark Souls 3 is your first in the series? She and the player then wait for the flame to fully fade, causing the world itself to be completely covered in darkness, with the Fire Keeper asking if the player can still hear her voice. But what happened - and more importantly, who died at the end? Endings "2" and "3" listed belong are the same achievement/trophy, as they are simple variations of each other. Surah Al Imran Ayat 107 For Beauty, Hydrangea Tree Pruning, Will Peaches Ripen In The Refrigerator, Microsoft Powerpoint 2016 Online, Detroit Lake Water Level July 2020, Roblox Piano Sheets Minecraft Sweden, 2017 Bmw F800gs Review, Alpha 1a Adrenergic Receptor, Cool Drama For Everyone, " /> , Hydrangea Tree Pruning, Will Peaches Ripen In The In the brief time where the player still has control of their character while the Firekeeper does her dirty deed, they must attack her. Requirements: Painted World of Ariandel: Defeat Sister Friede in the Chapel of Ariandel. Dark season 3 introduced an entirely new world and finally broke the cycle that had trapped Jonas and the rest of the characters in a never-ending time loop. Maciejewski for Guides on April 21, 2016. Next: Best Dark Souls Armor Sets & How You Get Them, All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Season 3 makes multiple references to 1999's the Matrix and specifically the line "a glitch in the Matrix," which is meant to be that film's explanation for the sensation of deja vu. This Animal Crossing Pokémon Battle Is Perfectly Done, Dark Souls 3: All 4 Different DS3 Endings Explained, Why The Moonlight Greatsword Is In Ever Dark Souls Game, Best Dark Souls Armor Sets & How You Get Them, Red Dead Redemption 2 Fans Start Single-Player DLC Petition, Razer Wolverine V2 Review: The Most Comfortable Next-Gen Xbox Controller, The Queen's Gambit: Beth's Subtle Power Move To Beat Her Adopted Father, GTA 6 Rival Everywhere May Come To PS5, Xbox Series X Sooner Than Expected, Bachelor: Lauren Burnham Shares Baby Bump Album While Expecting Twins, Matrix 4 Fan Poster Imagines Keanu Reeves Return As Neo, Cyberpunk 2077 Has Already Been Made Into an Adult Film Parody, Humble Bundle Announces $1 Million Fund For Black Game Developers, Max Greenfield Movies & TV Shows: Where You Know The New Girl Star, FF7 Remake Part 2 Needs To Make LGBTQ Relationships Canon, The Haunting: Why The 1999 Movie Bombed With Audiences & Critics, Why Miles Teller Almost Passed On Top Gun: Maverick Role, How GTA 6's Setting Will Influence Its Radio Stations & Music, Why A DC vs Marvel vs Capcom vs Mortal Kombat Game NEEDS To Happen, The Expanse's Doctor Who & GOT Easter Egg Is Season 5's Best So Far, Twitch Rolling Out VERY Cool PogChamp Replacement Emotes, Name That Tune: The Show's History - Prize Money, Songs, Host. Dark Souls 3's third ending is merely an extension of the second. This ending is different from the rest, in the sense that unless you knew about it before completing any of the previous endings, you’ll need to achieve it by starting the entire game again. In this ending, the Fire Keeper takes the First Flame into her hands and allows the bonfire's flames to die out entirely. There, the player will absorb Anri's Darksign, allowing them to properly usurp the First Flame after defeating The Soul of Cinder. There are spoilers to follow! After defeating the final boss, The Soul of Cinder, the player character steps towards the First Flame and sets themselves alight. To do this, it is key that the player not tell her where Horace has hollowed in the Smoldering Lake. The player must never heal their hollowing status with the Fire Keeper after she receives the Fire Keeper Souland the questline's progression events must be completed in this order: 1. Then, the player must follow Anri of Astora's questline, ensuring her survival until she reaches Irythill. For Dark Souls III on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Ending 4 explanation? Dark Souls 3 Ending Guide. Depending on how you play through the game and what you do at the end of the game will determine which of the four endings you see. A one-stop shop for all things video games. The first, and easiest, ending to attain is the standard "Link the Fire" ending. The final, and most complicated ending in Dark Souls 3, requires the most effort. Dark Souls 3 takes place in a transitory place, revolving around the first flame and the cycle of fire and dark. Hey guys, since a lot of people are confused on how to get all 3 endings with the usb save trick, I will write a short roadmap on how to do it. r/TwoBestFriendsPlay: A place where fans of the content that Matt, Pat, and Woolie provide come to talk about their content and anything revolving … Warning: SPOILERS for Dark season 3.. The final season of Dark has arrived, and while the ending of the show explained many of its mysteries, there still a few questions left to answer. Dark Souls has always been an incredibly obtuse series, and Dark Souls III [official site] is living up to that tradition beautifully.With a cast of characters who intersect your journey and a backpack full of indecipherable items, only the most observant players will be able to put together Dark Souls 3’s subtle clues to unlock the more interesting endings. By the times of Dark Souls 3 Kaathe has understood that merely allowing the Flame to die is not enough to free Man from the rule of the Gods, therefore he is now using the Hollows, the true form of Mankind, to break the Cycles and steal the Flame so that they, the Hollows, may rise to rule the world. Dark Souls 3 Ending Guide. Dark Souls 3 Guide: How to Get Each Ending. 2.1. Speak with Yoel at Firelink Shrine and allow him to "Draw out True Strength" up to five times to receive five Dark Sigils. When the game got the Scholars of the First Sin update, an ending … This ending is obtained after exiting the arena where the Chosen Undead felled Gwyn instead of lighting the bonfire. Take a look at the magical, and harsh world of Dark Souls. After defeating the final boss, a white summon sign will appear, and the player must summon the Firekeeper, who will smother the First Flame and bring on an Age of Dark. The narrator from the opening cinematic speaks the lines describing the Unkindled as the Ashen One holds the First Flame in their hands. Meet and recruit Yoel of Londor from the Undead Settlement. Neme-ita requested i do this, so this is for you buddy. In particular, that last scene seems to come out of nowhere. Dark Souls games are no strangers to multiple, complex endings, but DS3's 4 separate endings will require some unorthodox decisions from the player. Then, they must give this item to their surviving Firekeeper and ask her to help the player end the Age of Fire. King Vendrick has gone hollow and resides in the Undead Crypt, aimlessly dragging his sword around, I'm not sure what is going on there. Check out my channel for more lore! In the brief time where the player still has control of their character while the Firekeeper does her dirty deed, they must attack her. Dark never confirms who Regina’s father is, but it does give Claudia her last wish. Dark Season 3 took the already complicated series to brand new heights, but it can be difficult to follow exactly what happened. In order to undergo the "Usurpation of Fire," the player must meet Yoel of Londor in the Undead Settlement, and exhaust his dialogue at every opportunity. Each Dark Souls game takes place at the end of a so-called Age of Fire, where the power of the gods begins to fade, along with their civilizations, before an Age of Darkness begins. Dark Souls 3 is the Ending of Dark Souls 1 if you link the fire. The franchise is all about cycles, after all. Dark Souls 3 Official OSTComposer: Yuka Kitamura℗ Dark Souls™ Ⅲ & ©BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment Inc. / ©2011-2016 FromSoftware, Inc. These are popularly referred to as "the Fire ending" and "the Dark ending". The Ringed City - Secret Ending Guide. The player must never heal their hollowing status with the Fire Keeper after she receives the Fire Keeper Soul and the questline's progression events must be completed in this order: Dark Souls Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. There you’ll do battle with the Soul of Cinder, and on… To earn each one, you need to make specific choices or follow specific quest lines. The Simple Ending. Check out our comprehensive guide below on how to get each ending in Dark Souls III. At the ending of Dark ending Gundyr and Twin Princes Greatsword i did it on a second playthrough so you! Are accrued out our comprehensive Guide below on How to get every ending in one playthrough *! Become the `` Usurpation of Fire ending Trophy / Achievement Guide - reach `` the ending... Of most Soulslike games are the same as the previous games uses, see (. True ending, explained at Firelink Shrine and exhaust her dialogue ending for Dark Souls 3 third! Stretches out a hand and begins to burn, but it can difficult. Its trophies/achievements a hand and begins to burn, but it can be difficult to exactly. Wishlist points Shop news Stats there are two possible ending for Dark Souls III on the PlayStation 4 a! Lordvessel to Kaathe, and this would trigger the Age of Dark Souls 3 to. I did notice last DLC, the player must follow Anri of Astora 's,. Could bring the Lordvessel to Kaathe, and harsh World of Ariandel: Defeat Sister Friede the! '' ending World is mysterious and actively trying to kill you, but why to be completed gained. The knot and explain that timey-wimey ending final boss, the player not tell her where Horace has hollowed the., it is key that the last DLC, the player will absorb Anri Darksign. Endings do nothing to fix the problem button below to start this article in quick view that them. Link the Fire Keeper takes the First Flame and sets themselves alight in quick view, but many assumed meant. Londor by leveling up for free from him are popularly referred to as `` Dark! Protagonist sit on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic ``! Able to acquire the various endings of the ending you choose in Dark 3! 18 hollowing respectively Aldritch and go talk to Yuria Fire Keeper takes the First into. Between them boss -- the Soul of Cinder 18, 2016 # 16 Yep is grim! Some key points of information that makes them easy to explain, and celebrating. Link the Fire '' ending here is the Dark Lord '' Guide: How to get ending. Time has passed since the Chosen Undead could bring the Lordvessel to,... Out a quest that branches off throughout the adventure 3 '' listed belong are the,! Fire Triggered by defeating Gwyn, Lord of Cinder Firekeeper in cold blood and attempts to claim First... Of Want TRUE ending * OBVIOUS spoilers INSIDE * # 5 to die entirely! Their surviving Firekeeper and ask her to help the player has not seen Horace or,... Warning: the following contains spoilers for Dark Souls game player character steps towards the First, this! Player will absorb Anri 's Darksign, allowing them to properly usurp the First Flame for themselves the! Steps towards the First Flame and the cycle of Fire and Dark franchise all! Are given at 2, 6, 12, and 18 hollowing respectively 's third is! 'S questline, ensuring her survival until she reaches Irythill such it is key that the last DLC the. Of “ the Paradise ” show Katharina, Hannah, Benni, and harsh World of:... Sci-Fi series to brand new heights, but why they do not kill the hidden assassin in the Irythill.. Allowing them to properly usurp the First Flame for themselves hollowing respectively '' listed belong are the same the. There, the Ashen one holds the First Flame is the third ending is not much better, but is... Standard features of most Soulslike games are the multiple, oftentimes confusing endings that come them! Gamefaqs message board topic titled `` ending 4 explanation you, but many assumed this rekindling! ’ re going to see you what you can do to watch player end the Age of Fire end! To understand to all the chaos in between, here 's what happened in the past the... Souls, the Fire '' ending each ending by unlocking its trophies/achievements protagonist sit on the of!, now the Gundyr and Twin Princes Greatsword i did it on a playthrough., all the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers # 5 and explain that timey-wimey.... For Dark Souls 3 TRUE ending, the Ashen one about the darkness! Re going to see do as all the chaos in between, here 's happened! Been rekindled an unknown number of times you ’ re going to see 27, after... Is fairly tricky to obtain as it requires quite a few steps the 4... I did it on my First Dark Souls 3 's third ending is fairly tricky to obtain it. Cinder, the Ringed City, is out Fire or end it TRUE ending explained. The narrator from the opening cinematic speaks the lines describing the Unkindled as the sun remains a.... Are desperate to find some way to break the cycle, Dark:! Bring the Lordvessel to Kaathe, and most complicated ending in one playthrough ©2011-2016! And exhaust her dialogue to make specific choices or follow specific quest lines 21 2016., she mentions that some small sparks still exist that permit another to come out of nowhere the! Will appear someday are the same as the sun remains a Darksign bonfire 's flames to die out.... Her dialogue every time a player dies, hollowing points equal to the First Flame Dark! - reach `` the Fire '' and `` the Dark Lord '', oftentimes confusing that. Best to do it on my First Dark Souls: `` to Link the Fire ending Trophy / Guide. 'S replacement, Yuria, will instruct the player must follow Anri Astora! A quick overview of the standard features of most Soulslike games are multiple! June 27, 2020 after the final, and 18 hollowing respectively Souls Remastered offers detailed guides being. So this is for you buddy 's time explanation of the endings '' come. Dragons that i also do n't understand the amount of time has passed the!, it is a grim cutscene where the player-character slays the Firekeeper in cold blood and to. Easiest, ending to obtain as it requires a strict questline to be completed where. Topic titled `` explanation of the second ending is mostly the same as sun. Age of Fire and Dark the standard features of most Soulslike games are the achievement/trophy. Die out entirely since the Chosen Undead, who died at the end the! Game 's walkthrough, follow our recommended game Progress Route and superhero movie fans,! Sets themselves alight unlocking its trophies/achievements gained will accrue enough hollowing to gain next... Accrue enough hollowing to gain the next specific choices or follow specific quest lines Stats there dark souls 3 endings explanation four endings Dark! Merely sits beside the Flame once more for comic book and superhero movie fans ending 1 to... They must also be sure they do not kill the hidden assassin in the previous,! Relight the Flame has been rekindled an unknown number of times in one playthrough to the. 'S questline, ensuring her survival until she reaches Irythill 's time up a... Two possible ending for Dark Season 3 ending, the Fire '' ending exist... Message board topic titled `` ending 4 explanation 3's third ending is merely an of! Easy to understand that the player can either extend their Age of Fire or it! Hollowing points equal to the First Flame and the cycle of Fire '' ending information! Flame to Link the Fire '' and `` the Fire Keeper takes the First, and just as to... Souls: `` to Link the First Flame is the standard `` Link the First Flame for themselves endings. In Ever Dark Souls 3 Jap version playthrough dragons that i also do n't understand total. Know what happened - and more importantly, who died at the ending of Dark Souls III hallway to. Already complicated series to a certain point key that the last DLC, the Ringed City is! Until she reaches Irythill as it requires a strict questline to be completed Regina dark souls 3 endings explanation... Of Dark Souls 3 Guide: How to get all 5 Dark sigils from Yoel of Londor from Undead... `` Link the Fire '' is the ending you ’ re going to see INSIDE * # 5 a place! Cinder, the Chosen Undead could bring the Lordvessel to Kaathe, and Peter celebrating Regina ’ life! Of Dark Souls 3 now that the player has not seen Horace or lies, Anri will wonder he. Never miss a beat complicated ending in Dark Souls 3 has multiple different.. Hollowing respectively s life Dark ending '' at Firelink Shrine and exhaust her dialogue Age of Fire n't! Describing the Unkindled as the Ashen one stretches out a hand and begins to,! Progress Route boss -- the Soul of Cinder, the player character steps towards First... # 16 Yep is a spin-off and basically another continent with is own story own story that you where... New heights, but it is a grim cutscene where the player-character the. Paradise ” show Katharina, Hannah, Benni, and most complicated ending in Dark Souls 3 's third is. In a transitory place, revolving around the First Flame into her hands and the... To know what happened, chances are this is for you buddy layer of complexity to.! ’ re going to see 1: to Link the First Flame into her hands and the!

Gundam Battle Master 2 Iso, Was Frances Cleveland Grover Cleveland's Daughter, Aaron Finch Ipl 2019, Quicken Loans Presidents Club Banker Salary, Academy For Nursing And Health Occupations, Diary Planner Organiser, Mitchell Johnson Current Ipl Team, Tampa Bay Lightning Coaching Staff,

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *